Checklist: Preparing a Motif Collection for Licensing
A practical, step-by-step checklist for getting a motif collection pitch-ready — seamless repeats,...
Put a tartan scarf, a houndstooth coat and a herringbone jacket on the same rail and most people can name one of them with confidence. Move the scarf two hooks along and certainty collapses. All three are wool, all three are built on twill, and all three read as "patterned" from across a room — which is exactly why they get mixed up.
Here is the reassuring part: each one gives itself away quickly once you know what to look for. Two of them are weave structures. One is really a colour arrangement. And they behave very differently when you squint, when you trace a single line, and when you step back. The trick is not memorising three separate patterns. It is learning to ask three questions in the right order: Is there a grid of colours? Are the shapes jagged or chevron-shaped? And does the weave itself reverse direction?
Tartan is a colour recipe — a repeating sett of stripes and squares — that is usually woven in twill. Houndstooth is a two-colour broken check created by a specific twill arrangement. Herringbone is a twill weave that reverses direction at regular intervals, making a chevron. That is the whole family tree in one breath.
If you can see a plaid grid, think tartan. If you can see jagged teeth, think houndstooth. If you can see a quiet V-shaped spine, think herringbone.
All three are usually built on twill, which is why they feel like cousins. Twill is a weave where the weft thread passes over one or more warp threads and under two or more, creating a diagonal step. Denim is twill. Chino is twill. So is the diagonal line you see in a classic trench coat. That diagonal step gives twill its durability, drape and subtle sheen — and it is the reason tartan, houndstooth and herringbone can all look textured rather than flat.
But twill is only the starting point. The differences come from what happens next: how colours are arranged, how the twill is broken, and whether the diagonal changes direction.
Tartan is the odd one out because it is not really a weave structure. It is a sett: a fixed sequence of coloured stripes that repeats across the warp and the weft. When those stripes cross, they create new shades where the colours overlap. A red stripe crossing a blue stripe may read as purple. A thin yellow line may appear only at certain intersections. That is why tartan looks rich and deep rather than printed.
The classic tartan test is the grid. Step back and squint. You should see a square lattice of colour blocks, often with a dominant ground, bold bands, and thin accent lines. Traditional clan tartans like Black Watch, Royal Stewart or Campbell are built this way. So are fashion tartans that have no clan connection at all. The important thing is the repeat: it is symmetrical, it is colour-led, and it forms a plaid.
One common confusion: in North America, “plaid” often means any checked pattern. In Scotland, “plaid” can refer to a tartan cloth or a garment, while the pattern itself is the tartan. For identification purposes, just look for the colour grid. If the colours are doing the work, you are probably looking at tartan.
Houndstooth is a two-colour pattern — classically black and white, though any contrasting pair works — that looks like a broken check or a row of jagged teeth. It is woven, not printed, and its shape comes from a specific twill arrangement. In a simple houndstooth, four dark and four light ends alternate in a way that creates a pointed, interlocking shape. The result is a pattern that looks grey from a distance because the eye blends the two colours.
Look closely and you will see that houndstooth has no continuous diagonal line and no reversing chevron. Instead, the twill is broken into little step shapes. The classic large version is called houndstooth; smaller versions are often called puppytooth, pinhead or mini-houndstooth. A very large, bold version can look almost like a graphic checkerboard, but the edges are still jagged rather than straight.
Houndstooth is the pattern that looks like a check from far away and like a puzzle piece up close.
Herringbone is the purest weave structure of the three. It is a twill weave in which the direction of the diagonal reverses at regular intervals, creating a column of V shapes. Imagine a fish skeleton with the spine running vertically and the bones slanting out to either side. That is herringbone. The pattern is usually woven in a single colour or two closely related colours, so the effect is more textural than colourful.
Because herringbone relies on light and shadow, it can be subtle. A fine grey herringbone suit may look almost solid from a few feet away, then reveal its zigzag when you move closer or when the light catches it. A bold herringbone coat, by contrast, makes the chevron obvious. There are also variations: broken herringbone, where the chevrons are offset; double herringbone, where two lines of zigzag run together; and fishbone, which is similar but often has a different repeat and a more open, woven look.
If you are standing in a shop with all three on the rail, run this quick sequence.
That is usually enough. But there are edge cases. A tartan can be woven in a herringbone twill, which muddies the grid but still leaves the colour sett. A houndstooth can be woven in tartan colours, which makes it look festive but still jagged. A herringbone can be printed rather than woven, in which case it may lack the subtle sheen and depth of a true twill. When in doubt, touch the cloth and look at the reverse side. Woven patterns usually show their structure more clearly on the back.
Once you can tell them apart, the next skill is wearing them together. The three patterns can coexist, but scale and contrast matter more than category.
Scale is the other lever. A giant houndstooth can overwhelm a small frame; a micro-herringbone can disappear into a busy outfit. Tartan has its own scale in the sett: a small dress tartan reads as a fine check, while a large hunting tartan reads as a bold plaid. Hold the fabric at arm’s length and squint. Whatever you notice first is the pattern that will dominate.
If you are searching online or asking a tailor, the right words save time. Use tartan when you mean a specific colour sett, and name it if you can: Black Watch, Stewart, Fraser. Use houndstooth for the jagged two-colour check, and puppytooth for a small version. Use herringbone for the chevron twill, and broken herringbone or double herringbone if the zigzag is interrupted or doubled. Avoid calling everything “plaid” unless you are happy to be handed a tartan, a check, or a flannel shirt with equal probability.
Tartan, houndstooth and herringbone are not three random patterns. They are three answers to the same twill question. Tartan says: let colour build the grid. Houndstooth says: break the twill into jagged teeth. Herringbone says: reverse the twill into a chevron. Once you know which question you are looking at, the rail stops being a blur. The scarf, the coat and the jacket introduce themselves.
Photo: aiworldexplore / Pixabay
A practical, step-by-step checklist for getting a motif collection pitch-ready — seamless repeats,...
How warm and cool colours, value and contrast change the mood of a motif, plus three practical palette...
Turn sketches into stitch-ready embroidery files with practical steps for scanning, cleaning and...
